Best Mattresses Thrifter 2021

You might not realize quite how much time you spend in bed but, for many people, it's around a third of their lives. Whether or not you're getting your full eight hours of sleep, you should ensure that you have the best mattress possible so you can sleep well and make sure you wake up each day feeling refreshed.

Casper Original

Best overall: Casper Sleep Original Foam Mattress

Staff Pick

If you're looking for a mattress that gets the balance right between support and breathability, Casper's Original model is the one to go for. Available in sizes from twin to California king, it offers targetted support for proper spinal alignment and a perforated top foam layer to help move body heat away.

$1,083 at Amazon
Rivet Mattress

Affordable king: Rivet Mattress

Rivet, an Amazon brand, offers its own mattress to go with its variety of bed frames and headboards. It is one of the most affordable king mattresses out there and features a 3-layer design for great sleep. The top layer provides responsive support with the memory foam middle offering even weight distribution and the bottom layer providing stability.

$599 at Amazon
Serta Queen

Compact box: Simmons 7-Inch Memory Foam Mattress

If you prefer a thinner, memory foam mattress that can be delivered in an easy to maneuver box, Simmons' 7-inch model is for you. It features a gel memory foam top layer that allows airflow to keep you cool and comfortable throughout the night with a supportive base later for comfort all night.

$251 at Amazon
Purple Mattress

Grid design: The Purple Mattress

Purple's mattress features a unique grid support system that is designed to dynamically flex under pressure so your shoulders, hips, and back are fully supported. It also has thousands of open-air channels that help to keep you cool. It's also designed to isolate movement so one person turning over does not disturb others nearby.

$1,099 at Amazon
Lucid Firm

Firm or plush: Lucid 8-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress

Take your pick between firm or plush options with the Lucid gel memory foam mattress. The affordable 8-inch mattresses feature a bamboo charcoal-infused base foam for support with 1.5 inches of ventilating gel memory foam on top to regulate temperature while conforming to the body to ease pressure points.

$214 at Amazon
Tuft And Needle Mint

Luxury foam: Tuft & Needle Mint Mattress

Tuft & Needle's Mint mattress offers luxurious comfort with its adaptive foam and luxe knit cover. It has a firm base layer with a middle layer of foam that features ceramic gel beads for a progressive, supportive feel. On top is the T&N Adaptive foam layer which contours to your body shape while drawing heat away from your body as you sleep.

$931 at Amazon

Sweet dreams

When picking a new mattress, it's important to do the research so you make the right choice. It's a purchase you don't make often and it can be an expensive one, plus you'll have to live with the consequences every night if you get it wrong. This is the main reason we recommend the Casper Original as our top pick as it checks most boxes for most mattress buyers with its balance of comfort, breathability, convenient delivery, and price. Plus, you can return it should you not like it.

There are more affordable options, like the Simmons and Lucid mattresses, which may serve a purpose in a guest room or for a growing child, and way more premium options should you want to go all-out on your next mattress buy. Most can be delivered in small boxes these days so you don't have to worry about pivoting it up the stairs into your bedroom.

We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.